Apple: Thank You for Leaving Flash Out

Something has been weighing heavy on my mind for a while now. Years, in fact. I didn’t realize it however until the past few weeks while delving back into interactive media for the book publishing industry.

In the mid to late 90′s I spent a lot of effort on interactive media for desktop computers and commercial television. There were promising technologies and great multimedia development platforms, and out of this open specifications emerged like SMIL (Synchronized Multimedia Integration Language) and SVG (Scalable Vector Graphics), while HTML (HyperText Markup Language) flourished.

Interactive tools were built upon the shoulders of visionary products developed in the late ’80s and early ’90s like Hypercard, Macromedia Director, and AmigaVision.

SMIL was quickly adopted by Quicktime, Windows Media Player, and Real Player – the trifecta of heavy-weight vendors with a vested interest in interactive media. It was very promising that these vendors could all gather around this common open format for interactive media.

This was at the same time as Flash was also starting to take hold in the market.

Then over the following 10 years, SMIL was virtually assassinated from the landscape.

There’s a lot that can be written about SMIL and SVG’s failure in the industry.

Quicktime X no longer opens and runs SMIL files (Quicktime Player 7 does, and it’s still in the spec). Quicktime on the iPhone won’t handle SMIL. WYSIWYG SMIL editors now are nowhere to be found. Evolution of the SMIL specification slowed to a crawl. The once potentially vibrant ecosystem around open standards has withered to nearly nothing – with obscure projects like Ambulant remaining as last-chance efforts to keep an open format available to the world for interactive media.

My problem with Flash isn’t its capabilities – they are impressive. It is with the fact that it is a vendor proprietary format, with a closed ecosystem. Adobe makes the flash player. Adobe makes the flash development tools. Sure some other companies provide streamlined development tools based on Adobe’s APIs (like SWiSH Max) but Adobe controls what they can and can’t do with those APIs.

Apple is rallying behind emerging and open interactive formats like HTML, which have recently been trying to introduce new features like Video and provide a richer standardized interactive format – strangely what the world seems to be crying for all the time we let SMIL wither and die. Can you imagine what things would be like if HTML were a vendor-proprietary format? What would the world be like if Microsoft owned HTML? Adobe? Apple? Commodore?

In HTML / JavaScript you can build basic iPhone apps that look and feel just like native iPhone apps. For years now I’ve argued that most of what you see in Flash has been available using Dynamic HTML techniques pioneered 10 years ago – and standardized and popularized years ago among savvy web developers with libraries like Script.aculo.us and jQuery.

What we continue to lack are modern versions of the great pioneering multimedia tools. Classic HTML tools don’t cut it – we need tools that average computer users can grasp, that they DID grasp 20 years ago but we seem to have lost. That a teacher can sit down and use to build an interactive aid for students. That a marketing professional can use to build an interactive product demonstration. That aren’t tied to a vendor proprietary format. That will play natively in a web browser as intended by the author.

So I say to Apple, help us remember that Flash is just ONE option in the world of interactive media. Help us to remember that websites don’t need Flash to be highly interactive and graphically rich. Help us to remember that we need tooling and support for open standards and to realize the interactive multimedia vision that seemed so clear 20 years ago.

Ignore the whining from the complacent and lazy market, stick to your guns, and KEEP FLASH OFF the iPhone / iPad!

About these ads

4 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. Richard Gauder
    Jan 29, 2010 @ 15:03:47

    And search engines currently don’t read Flash. Even more important, it’s not accessible.

    Reply

  2. Sheldon
    Jan 29, 2010 @ 15:07:09

    i agree some great points. I think if the market keeps supporting the iphone/ipad, etc… that eventually more will end up developing for HMTL/Javscript type. BUT I don’t think it has anything to do with Apple attempting to be “free”… they are notorius for overcontrol. I personally wouldn’t keep my iphone if I couldn’t jailbreak. The Ipad would be useless longterm to me unless I could jailbreak. No multiasking? Eeek. They need to think a little less controlling, but good luck on that.

    Reply

  3. Lee Kichko
    Jan 30, 2010 @ 17:54:19

    Richard,

    Flash may not offer a way for a search engine to index the pages(although I’ve never personally looked into it), but Silverlight 3 actually does have something in the SEO department via navigation framework and deep linking. As for accessibility I’m not sure what compliance you would be looking for.. I see some results from the w3s and Silverlight 2(old), and has been improved since Silverlight 2(Silverlight 4 is in beta).

    http://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/WCAG20/implementation-report/Silverlight_accessibility_support_statement

    Unfortunately Expressions Blends is PC only:(

    Reply

  4. damian
    Feb 01, 2010 @ 14:32:20

    I am sorry but I had to chime in and correct some really incorrect statements, yes you can index flash properly, the company that I work for was just given an award for this by google’s Avanish Kaushik. This is just a classic example of steve jobs being protectionist. I am a true mac lover and have about 30 of them but lets discuss things with a few more facts.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 109 other followers

%d bloggers like this: